Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Evan Booyens's avatar

I would argue for proportional votes. Those that pay personal income tax get 1 extra vote. This does not sound like a big thing but can shift the balance over time. This also does not remove the vote from non-taxpayers which will cause problems. Everyone gets a say, but those with skin in the game get more say.

PIET DU PLESSIS's avatar

Perhaps if a future SA constitutional dispensation allows for greater self-determination by local communities and smaller groups with shared interests, local taxes could be paid locally for the develoment needs of those specific communities. A Federal Tax on all can be levied, but with the various self-determining communities still having a say in the extraction and expenditure of those taxes in accordance with their proportional contributions to the federal tax pool.

In effect, the forgoing is already happening in South Africa, but informally. Communities established organisations to properly do what the governmental sector fails to do or fails to maintain properly. Those communities also pay a "federal tax", which they have little say over because of all that was explained by Nicholas in the article...

2 more comments...

Ready for more?